5 reasons why you should opt for a full fence replacement over a fence repair

Richmond Hill is one of the fastest-growing communities in the Greater Toronto Area, boasting beautiful residential neighbourhoods like Oak Ridges, Bayview Hill, and Jefferson. As homeowners here strive to maintain both the aesthetic appeal and value of their properties, they often face the decision of whether to repair their existing fence or invest in a complete replacement. While a fence repair might seem more convenient and cost-effective in the short term, opting for a full fence replacement offers several long-term advantages. Partnering with a reliable fence contractor in Richmond Hill ensures the job is done right.

1. Structural Integrity and Durability

Richmond Hill experiences a wide range of weather conditions—from cold, snowy winters to hot, humid summers—that can cause significant wear and tear on fences over time. According to weather data from the City of Richmond Hill, the region experiences an average of 150 days of precipitation each year, with heavy snowfalls in winter and high humidity in summer. This constant exposure to moisture can weaken fence materials, especially wood, causing warping, rotting, and rust.

A fence that has already sustained years of damage may have compromised structural integrity. Patching up weak points won't address the overall deterioration. By opting for a full fence replacement with experienced fencing companies in Richmond Hill, you’ll ensure your fence is built to withstand local weather for many years, protecting your investment in the long run.

2. Long-Term Cost Efficiency

Richmond Hill’s booming real estate market makes a strong case for home improvements that offer long-term value. According to data from the Toronto Real Estate Board, property values in Richmond Hill have been consistently on the rise, with an average home price of over $1.4 million as of 2023. Investing in a full fence replacement instead of recurring repairs helps to maintain or even increase the value of your home.

Although a repair may seem cheaper initially, repeated maintenance can become expensive. By working with a fence contractor to install a new, durable fence, you'll avoid ongoing repair costs and extend the life of your fence. Furthermore, modern fencing materials like pressure-treated wood or vinyl, often recommended by fencing companies, are more resistant to Richmond Hill’s environmental stresses and can lower your maintenance costs over time.

3. Boosting Curb Appeal

Richmond Hill neighbourhoods, such as the scenic Mill Pond or the historic downtown area, are known for their well-maintained homes and attractive landscapes. Your fence is a key part of your home's first impression. An older, weathered fence—no matter how well-maintained—can detract from the overall appearance of your property. Repairing individual sections may not restore its aesthetic value.

A new fence installed by a professional fences company will not only enhance your home's curb appeal but also complement the local community's standards. Whether you live near landmarks like Richmond Green Sports Centre and Park or along Yonge Street, a fresh, well-designed fence will help your home stand out in a competitive real estate market.

4. Compliance with Richmond Hill Fencing Regulations

The City of Richmond Hill has specific fencing bylaws in place to ensure uniformity and safety within its neighbourhoods. For example, residential fences cannot exceed 2.2 meters in height in the backyard, and they must be set back from the property line by a certain distance, depending on the fence type and location. Older fences may not meet these updated regulations, especially if they were built years ago. 

By opting for a full fence replacement, you can ensure that your new installation is fully compliant with the city’s current bylaws. Experienced fence companies in Richmond Hill will be familiar with local regulations and can handle the process of ensuring that your fence meets all legal requirements, saving you from potential fines or forced modifications down the road.

5. Enhanced Safety and Security

In neighbourhoods like Langstaff and Elgin Mills, where families with children and pets are common, the safety and security provided by a fence are paramount. Older fences that have been compromised by weather or damage may no longer offer the protection your family needs. A well-installed, sturdy fence replacement provides peace of mind, knowing your property is secure from intruders and your pets and children are safe within your yard.

Many fence companies like Richmond Hill Fence offer options like taller fences, reinforced gates, and additional security features, giving you more options to customize your new fence to meet your safety needs. With a full replacement, you're also investing in the long-term security of your Richmond Hill home.

Some FAQs:

​Who fixes a broken fence?

If your fence is damaged in Richmond Hill, the best option is to hire a professional fencing company like Richmond Hill Fence. Whether it’s weather damage from a recent storm or wear and tear over time, we have helped homeowners restore their fences to top condition. In some cases, minor repairs like replacing a few boards or reinforcing posts can extend the life of your fence, while more extensive damage may require a partial or full replacement.

Who is responsible for the other side of the fence?

Fence ownership in Richmond Hill depends on property lines and agreements between neighbours. Typically, if the fence is built directly on the property line, both neighbours share responsibility for its maintenance and repairs. However, if a homeowner installed the fence fully on their own property, they are solely responsible. We've worked with homeowners in Oak Ridges who successfully split repair costs with their neighbours after consulting Richmond Hill’s local bylaws and property surveys to clarify ownership. It’s always best to have an open conversation with your neighbour before making any changes.

Can a wood fence be repaired?

Yes, a wood fence can often be repaired rather than fully replaced, depending on the extent of the damage. In Richmond Hill, we’ve helped homeowners in Jefferson and Rouge Woods reinforce leaning fences by securing new posts and replacing rotting or broken boards. If a few pickets or panels are damaged, replacing them can be a cost-effective solution. However, if the fence is severely deteriorated or structurally unsound, a full replacement may be the better long-term investment. Keep in mind that extensive damage may present as minimal damage, so ask your fence contractor to do a proper assessment.  Proper maintenance, like staining or sealing the wood, can also prevent future damage and extend the fence’s lifespan.


Final Thoughts

Choosing a full fence replacement over repairs offers Richmond Hill homeowners numerous benefits, including enhanced durability, long-term cost savings, increased curb appeal, and better compliance with local regulations. With the city's unique climate and bylaws, partnering with a professional fences company ensures your new fence is built to last and meet all legal requirements. 

If you're considering a fence upgrade, Richmond Hill is the perfect place to make a long-term investment in your property. Contact us today to discuss your options and ensure your home remains both beautiful and secure for years to come.

---